Feet crossed on top of a kayak with the soles of the sandals showing.

Rubber vs. EVA Soles for Sandals

by Mark Paigen 9 minute read

Choosing the right sole for your sandals can significantly impact comfort, durability, and overall enjoyment. This guide delves into the specifics of rubber versus EVA (ethylene-vinyl acetate) soles. It provides a thorough analysis to assist you in making an informed decision for your next pair of sandals.


The Basics: TL;DR ---

  • Outsoles. The sole of a sandal is the bottom layer that comes in direct contact with the ground, crucial for traction, durability, and protecting the foot.

  • Durability. Rubber soles surpass EVA in resistance to wear and tear, making them more durable and longer-lasting.

  • Cushioning. EVA soles provide superior cushioning and comfort, but sacrifice stability and support in the process.

  • Weight & Flexibility. EVA outsoles are lighter and more flexible than rubber, but rubber balances weight and flexibility with durability.

  • Traction. Rubber outsoles provide better grip and slip resistance on various surfaces, making them a better choice for outdoor and wet conditions.

  • Sustainability. Rubber tends to have less of an environmental impact compared to EVA.

  • Cost. While EVA soles may be cheaper initially, rubber soles offer better long-term value. Their durability makes rubber soles more cost-effective in the long-run.


What You Need To Know---

Choosing between rubber and EVA soles for sandals hinges on understanding each material's unique benefits. Rubber soles excel in durability and traction making them perfect for those who value long-lasting wear and outdoor versatility. EVA soles are more suited for light leisure activities.

Rubber soles emerge as the more sustainable and economical choice over time. Understanding the key differences between rubber and EVA will help you find the pair of sandals that meets both your comfort and durability needs.

 Shop Sandals with Rubber Soles

Table of Contents

    1. Sandal Anatomy
    2. Understanding Sole Materials
    3. Comparative Analysis: Rubber vs. EVA Soles
    4. FAQs
    5. Rubber vs. EVA Soles for Sandals: Which One Should I Choose?


        Understanding Sandal Anatomy

        Before we dive deeper into the specifics of sole materials, it's essential to understand the different parts of a sandal. Each component plays a crucial role in the overall functionality, comfort, and durability of the footwear. Here's a quick breakdown of the main parts of a sandal:
        • Straps. These are the parts that hold the sandal on your foot. They are often polyester, nylon, or leather.

        • Midsole (or "Footbed"). This is the layer that your foot rests on. It's designed for comfort and support. Midsoles are made from various materials, including PU, EVA, rubber, or cork.

        • Top Cover Material. The midsole is sometimes topped with an additional material layer that prevents slipping and enhances comfort. This top cover can be leather, a synthetic fabric, or microfiber.

        • Outsole (or "Sole"): The very bottom layer of the sandal, the outsole comes in direct contact with the ground. It's responsible for traction, durability, and protecting the foot from rough surfaces. EVA and rubber are two of the most common types of soles.  The sole material significantly impacts the sandal's performance in different environments.

        Anatomy of a sandal diagram showing the straps, top cover, midsole/footbed, and outsole/sole.

        Understanding these components helps clarify discussions about sandal materials. This is especially important when comparing the benefits and drawbacks of rubber vs. EVA soles. Knowing that the "sole" refers specifically to the outsole allows for a more informed consideration of sole material type.


        Understanding Shoe Sole Materials

        Rubber Soles

        Rubber is a durable and flexible material that is widely used in the soles of shoes and sandals designed for outdoor activities. Recognizable by its heavier feel and distinct smell, rubber soles are often found in hiking sandals and other footwear requiring superior traction and water resistance. You can identify rubber soles by their firm density that will compress very little when pressed.

        Tread Labs Sandal sole

        EVA (Ethylene-Vinyl Acetate) Soles

        EVA soles are made from a lightweight, foam-like polymer that offers excellent cushioning. Common in running shoes and casual sandals, EVA is known for its soft, plush feel underfoot. To identify EVA soles, look for a smoother, matte finish that compresses easily under pressure.

        EVA Sandal Sole 

        Comparative Analysis: Rubber vs. EVA Soles

        When deciding between rubber and EVA as a shoe sole material, it's important to compare all the factors to determine which material best suits your needs. From everyday wear to specialized activities, the choice of sole material can impact the sandal's performance, comfort, and lifespan. Let's delve into a detailed comparison, starting with the chart below that highlights key factors and following up with an indepth analysis.


        Rubber Soles EVA Soles
        Durability & Longevity
        Highly durable and abrasion resistant Less durable, compresses and wears down faster.
        Cushioning & Comfort
        Offers support, less immediate cushioning. More cushioning but at the expense of reliable support.
        Weight & Flexibility Heavier, offers stability with moderate flexibility. Lightweight, highly flexible.
        Traction & Slip Resistance Excellent grip on various surfaces, slip-resistant. Adequate traction, less effective on slippery surfaces.
        Environmental Impact & Sustainability More eco-friendly when natural or recycled rubber is used.  Durability improves sustainability. Less eco-friendly, petroleum-based and does not biodegrade. Recycled EVA is more eco-friendly.
        Cost Generally more expensive, offers better long-term value. More affordable upfront, but will require more frequent replacement.

        Durability and Longevity

        • Rubber Soles. Rubber stands out for its exceptional durability, making it the go-to choice for footwear designed to endure harsh conditions and heavy use. Rubber's robust composition resists abrasion and wear, allowing it to maintain its shape and functionality over time.

          This makes rubber-soled sandals a wise investment for active, outdoor activities and for people seeking long-lasting options for daily wear. Its robust durability ensures that the sandals remain supportive even with prolonged use.
        • EVA Soles. While EVA offers comfort and flexibility, it doesn't match rubber in terms of longevity. EVA tends to compress and wear down quickly, especially under constant weight or in abrasive conditions.

          This compression can lead to a loss of cushioning and support over time, affecting the overall comfort and effectiveness of the sandals. For light activities or casual use, sandals with EVA soles may work for the short-term, but they will require more frequent replacement than sandals with rubber soles.
        For individuals prioritizing durability and a longer lifespan in their sandals, rubber soles are the superior choice. EVA soles, while comfortable and lightweight, will not provide the same level of long-term durability.  Eva soles are better suited for short-term, casual use.

        Comfort and Cushioning

        When it comes to the comfort and cushioning provided by sandals, the material of the midsole will play the most pivotal role in defining the wearer's experience.  The outsole is generally a thin layer on the bottom of the midsole so it tends to have less of an affect on a sandal's cushioning, regardless of the material.

        In some cases however, the midsole and the outsole are one single piece.  This is often true for cheaper EVA sandals. In this case the material choice will significantly impact comfort and cushioning.
        • Rubber Soles. Rubber soles provide a firm walking surface. This firmness translates into excellent support and stability. Rubber will not provide the same level of immediate, soft cushioning as EVA. Tread Labs Albion combines a rubber sole with a lightweight PU (polyurethane) midsole.  This gives the sandal the cushioned feel of EVA but with the durability of PU and rubber.
        • EVA Soles. EVA stands out for its exceptional cushioning. The material's foam-like quality creates a soft, plush feel underfoot, making it ideal for maximizing comfort in casual and light activity sandals.  EVA is better suited as a midsole material than an outsole material.

        For those requiring a balance of support, stability, and moderate cushioning, rubber-soled sandals will be the best choice.  

        Hand holding a pair of Tread Labs sandals by the heel straps.

        Weight and Flexibility

        The weight and flexibility of a sandal are largely determined by the material of the midsole, but a thick outsole can still affect a sandal's weight and flex.
        • Rubber Soles. Rubber soles are inherently heavier. This weight can provide a sense of durability and sturdiness. However, excessively thick rubber soles may add extra weight that leads to fatigue faster. Rubber offers reasonable flexibility but it is generally more rigid than EVA. This rigidity supports stability and can help protect your feet from sharp rocks.
        • EVA Soles. EVA is known for its lightweight properties. Sandals with EVA soles are light on the feet, reducing fatigue and making them suitable for leisure activities where minimizing foot strain is desired. EVA's flexibility may make sandals feel comfortable right out of the box, but this same composition makes EVA soles less durable and more prone to cracking and wear.
        If you prioritize a lightweight sandal that offers high flexibility for infrequent light activities, EVA soles may be a good choice. On the other hand, for those requiring a more robust, stable foundation for everyday use, rubber soles provide a better balance of weight, flexibility, and durability.  

        Traction and Slip Resistance

        The ability of sandals to grip surfaces and prevent slips is crucial, especially in wet or uneven conditions. This is where the sole material plays the most pivotal role.
        • Rubber Soles. Rubber is renowned for its superior traction on a wide variety of surfaces. Rubber soles are ideal for activities near water, such as beach outings, river trekking, or in urban environments prone to rain. Rubber-soled sandals are the go-to option for outdoor activities where reliable footing is critical.

        • EVA Soles. EVA soles provide adequate traction for dry, light activity. They do not offer the same level of grip as rubber, especially on wet or very uneven surfaces. The smoother texture of EVA can compromise its ability to securely grip certain surfaces. EVA soles are more prone to slipping in wet conditions.
        Rubber soles are the superior choice for those needing dependable traction across various activities, especially in wet or uneven conditions. EVA soles are best suited for casual wear and activities in controlled environments.

        Environmental Impact and Sustainability

        The environmental impact of sandal soles is an important consideration for eco-conscious consumers.
        • Rubber Soles. Natural rubber, derived from the latex of rubber trees, is one of the most eco-friendly options. Petroleum-based, synthetic rubber has a higher carbon footprint, but this can be offset by incorporating recycled content into the rubber soles.  The durability of rubber soles means less frequent replacements, significantly reducing waste over time and improving sustainability.
        • EVA Soles. EVA is a synthetic material that is not biodegradable, raising concerns about its long-term environmental impact. The production of EVA involves petroleum and chemical processes that contribute to pollution. The shorter lifespan of EVA soles, leading to more frequent replacements, contributes to more waste.

        Cost Comparison

        When it comes to the soles, the material used plays a role in the overall cost of the footwear.
        • Rubber Soles. Sandals with rubber soles tend to be on the higher end of the price spectrum. The cost is attributed to rubber's durability, superior traction, and more complex manufacturing process. While the initial investment may be higher, the longevity of rubber soles means better value over time, as the need for replacements is less frequent.
        • EVA Soles. EVA-soled sandals are typically more affordable due to the lower cost of materials and a simpler manufacturing process. This makes them an attractive option for budget-conscious consumers looking for comfortable and lightweight footwear. EVA's faster wear rate will create a need for more frequent replacements, potentially increasing the long-term cost.
        While EVA soles offer an economical upfront cost, rubber soles provide better long-term value. Consumers should weigh the initial cost against expected lifespan and usage patterns to make the most cost-effective choice.


        Image of men's feet wearing Tread Labs sandals, balancing on railroad tracks  


        What material is best for the sole of shoes?

        The best material for shoe soles depends on the wearer's needs and the shoe's intended use. For durability, traction, and long-term wear, rubber is often considered the superior choice, especially for outdoor or rugged activities. For lightweight comfort and flexibility, EVA stands out as a viable option, particularly for leisure or light activity footwear.

        Which is a better sole material, rubber or EVA?

        Rubber is generally the better sole material for those seeking durability, superior traction, and longevity in their footwear. It excels in outdoor and challenging environments, offering unmatched wear resistance and safety on various terrain. EVA, while offering excellent cushioning and lightness, does not provide the same level of durability and traction as rubber.

        What is the toughest shoe sole material?

        Rubber is renowned for being the toughest shoe sole material, capable of withstanding harsh conditions, extensive wear, and providing reliable traction across diverse landscapes. Its resilience and material integrity make it the go-to material for footwear designed for durability and rugged use.

        What is a long-lasting shoe sole material?

        For a long-lasting shoe sole material, rubber once again stands out. Its natural durability and resistance to abrasion allow it to maintain performance and structural integrity over years of use. Rubber soles are ideal for anyone looking for footwear that remains reliable and supportive over the long haul, minimizing the need for frequent replacements.  

        Rubber vs. EVA Soles for Sandals: Which One Should I Choose?

        When choosing between sandals with rubber soles or sandals with EVA soles, consider your activities and what you value in footwear. Rubber soles stand out for their unmatched durability and superior traction, making them ideal for both daily wear and outdoor adventures. They offer long-lasting support and robust performance, providing excellent value over time despite a higher initial cost.

        For those prioritizing a balance of performance and environmental sustainability, rubber recycled content is one of the best materials for shoe soles. Rubber soles outperform EVA in challenging conditions and longevity. Opting for rubber-soled sandals means investing in reliability, safety, and durability.

         Shop Sandals with Rubber Soles

        Back to blog